Vertical Economies of Scope in Electricity Supply: Analysing the Costs of Ownership Unbundling

  • Motivated by the movement towards ownership unbundling in Europeʹs energy sector, this PhD study analyses the cost effects of a vertical separation of the electricity supply stages from a theoretical and an empirical perspective. I covers the results of three research articles. The first article provides a literature review of previous theoretical and empirical studies on vertical scope economies. The measurement of these integration economies quantifies the expected cost increases that result from separating the electricity supply stages. Results are presented for different types of unbundling, as cost effects depend on the precise location of the ownership split along the supply chain. Efficiency losses may occur due to coordination effects and market risk effects. Reviewing previous studies shows that pure ʺnetwork unbundlingʺ, i.e. a separation networks from the competitive stages generation and retail, results in synergy losses between 2 and 5 percent due to coordination costs. Unbundling options that lead to a separation between generation and retail lead to a permanent cost increase of 15 percent and more due to the additional market risk effect. The second article confirms these results by applying a multi-stage cost function approach. Results show that separating generation from retail appears to be the most costly alternative with an average cost increase of 12 to 17 percent. The European case of transmission unbundling leads to a cost increase of approximately 4 percent. The third article presents an empirical study based on a frontier benchmarking approach that compares different ʺefficiency frontiersʺ for integrated and separate provision of electricity. Similar to the econometric study, a generation-retail split is the most costly option with an average cost increase of 18 percent (coordination and risk effects), while transmission unbundling leads to an average cost increase below 2 percent (coordination effects).

Download full text

Cite this publication

  • Export Bibtex
  • Export RIS

Citable URL (?):

Search for this publication

Search Google Scholar Search Catalog of German National Library Search OCLC WorldCat Search Catalog of GBV Common Library Network Search Catalog of Jacobs University Library Search Bielefeld Academic Search Engine
Meta data
Publishing Institution:IRC-Library, Information Resource Center der Jacobs University Bremen
Granting Institution:Jacobs Univ.
Author:Roland Meyer
Referee:Gert Brunekreeft, Adalbert Wilhelm, Christoph Weiss
Advisor:Gert Brunekreeft
Persistent Identifier (URN):urn:nbn:de:101:1-2013052812459
Document Type:PhD Thesis
Date of Successful Oral Defense:2011/04/12
Date of First Publication:2011/04/12
PhD Degree:Economics
School:SHSS School of Humanities and Social Sciences
Library of Congress Classification:H Social Sciences / HD Industries. Land use. Labor [incl. Management] / HD9000-9999 Special industries and trades / HD9502-9502.5 Energy industries. Energy policy. Fuel trade
Call No:Thesis 2011/11

$Rev: 13581 $